For many motorists, receiving a fine on their windscreen is a stressful event. However, it is crucial to understand that not all parking tickets are the same. A Parking Charge Notice (PCN) issued on private land is fundamentally different from a **Penalty Charge Notice (PCN)** issued by a local authority or the police.
These private fines result from committing a parking offence while using private property—such as a supermarket car park, a retail outlet, or a railway station—and they operate under entirely different rules and regulations. Crucially, they have their own specific methods of appeal, which is why knowing the distinction is vital.
The rules for private parking are often not as clear as they should be before you enter the car park. Did you know that by parking in a private car park space, you are effectively entering into a **contract** between you (the registered keeper of the vehicle in the DVLA database) and the car park operator? This means you are agreeing to their terms and conditions upon entry, often without explicitly realizing it.
For that reason, we have outlined everything you need to know here, from legal definitions and differences in fines to the precise process of appeal should you receive a charge.
What is a Parking Charge Notice (PCN)?
A **Parking Charge Notice** is a demand for payment resulting from a parking infringement on private land or in a car park operated by private organizations on behalf of the landowner. These are not enforced by the local highways authority or the police. This distinction is critical because it determines your legal liability and your right to appeal.
If you are issued this type of fine, you are liable to a Parking Charge Notice (Private PCN), as opposed to a local-authority-issued parking ticket, which is a Penalty Charge Notice (Local Authority PCN).
Typically, car parks that issue private PCNs are found at high-traffic, commercial locations:
- Airports and railway stations
- Supermarkets and fast food restaurants
- Out-of-town retail outlets and shopping parks
- Private residential or coastal car parks
Spotting the Difference: Private vs. Local Authority
If you receive a fine, it will likely be in a yellow plastic packet on your windscreen. While both types of fines use the confusingly similar acronym 'PCN', a quick check of the wording is essential:
- Private Land: The notice will usually say 'Parking Charge Notice'. This indicates the operator believes you have breached the terms of a contract.
- Local Authority/Police: The notice will say 'Penalty Charge Notice' or 'Fixed Penalty Notice'. This is a statutory fine enforced by law.
If the private operator is a member of an accredited trade association—such as the British Parking Association (BPA) or the International Parking Committee (IPC)—the ticket must clearly give reasons for the contravention, methods to pay, and, most importantly, contain information on how you can launch an appeal.
The Contractual Basis of Private Parking
The legal foundation of a private parking fine in England and Wales relies on the law of contract. When you drive your vehicle onto a private car park, the signage acts as an "offer" of a contract. By proceeding to park, you "accept" the terms of that contract, including the consequence (the PCN charge) if you break those terms (e.g., overstaying, parking out of the bay).
Key Facts You Need to Know
- Unlawful Clamping: In England, Wales, and Scotland, clamping or towing a vehicle on private land without lawful authority (such as specific local by-laws, which are rare) is generally **illegal** since 2012. If your car is being or has been clamped, you are within your rights to call the police to report it.
- On-the-Spot Demands: If someone demands a penalty amount from you on the spot, you should contact the police. However, if an attendant asks only for the standard fee for an extra half-hour of parking (i.e., no penalty), this is generally seen as a reasonable charge for services rendered.
- The DVLA Data Link: Private parking companies rely on obtaining the registered keeper's details from the DVLA to issue the PCN by post if a ticket is not placed on the windscreen. This practice is legally permitted, linking the liability for the charge to the registered keeper.
Strategies for Avoiding a Parking Charge Notice
Prevention is always better than cure. By adopting a few defensive parking habits, you can significantly reduce your risk of receiving a private PCN:
- Scrutinize the Signage: Make it a habit to actively look for signs detailing the terms and conditions immediately upon entry. If signs are hard to find, obscured, or illegible, this may stand you in good stead should you receive a PCN and choose to appeal.
- Mind the Lines: Always ensure your vehicle is parked entirely within the marked bays. Operators are known to ticket motorists who have parked over the lines, even slightly, as this constitutes a breach of the terms.
- Disabled Bays: Do not park in disabled bays unless you have a valid blue badge clearly displayed.
- Note Time and Payment: Note the time you are allowed to park and when you actually parked. Set a clear timer or alarm on your phone/watch to remind yourself when you are due back.
- The Grace Period Rule: Unlike local authority parking in England, where a 10-minute grace period is statutory, there is no automatic statutory grace period for private land. However, operators who are members of the BPA (British Parking Association) are supposed to abide by the BPA Code of Practice, which mandates that drivers must be given a **10-minute grace period** after the ticket expires before a notice can be issued. If you can prove you were ticketed within this 10-minute window, you have strong grounds for appeal.
How to Effectively Appeal a Parking Charge Notice
An appeal should be launched in any incident where you genuinely feel you have not breached the terms and conditions, or if you feel the fine is disproportionate to the alleged offense.
Step 1: Do NOT Pay (The Admission of Guilt)
Firstly, if you feel you have been unfairly charged, do NOT pay anything. Paying immediately online or sending a cheque in the post is legally interpreted as an admission of guilt (liability for the contractual breach), and you cannot then subsequently appeal the charge.
Step 2: Gather Comprehensive Evidence
The time you receive the ticket is the most crucial time to gather evidence. Your appeal will hinge on documented facts:
- Photographs of Signage: Take multiple photos of all nearby parking signs, showing the terms and conditions, and any signposting indicating the size of the font or its location.
- Vehicle Position: Take pictures showing exactly how your vehicle was parked, demonstrating it was within the bay or that the lines were faded/unclear.
- Proof of Time: Keep the original parking ticket (if you paid), keep receipts if you were accused of going off-site, and note the time the PCN was issued.
- Date and Time: Note the precise date and time of the alleged contravention.
Step 3: Lodge the Initial Appeal with the Operator
An appeals process always requires that in the first instance, you lodge a formal appeal with the parking operator itself. The easiest way is usually online via their website.
- Reduced Rate: Many private operators will offer a reduced charge if you pay within 14 days (e.g., £60 instead of £100). Crucially, appealing in the first instance will **retain your right to pay at this reduced rate** even if the operator rejects your appeal.
- Accreditation Check: Always check whether the operator is a member of the BPA or the IPC. Review their respective code of practice to see whether the operator has acted in accordance and whether the reason for their ‘ticket’ is appropriate (e.g., failure to observe the 10-minute grace period for BPA members).
Step 4: Independent Appeal (POPLA or IAS)
If your initial appeal to the operator is rejected, you will be given a notice of rejection that includes details on how to appeal to an independent body. This next step is free for motorists, but you must know which body applies:
- POPLA (Parking on Private Land Appeals): POPLA will only consider appeals against Parking Charge Notices issued by an operator who is a member of the British Parking Association (BPA). POPLA is generally viewed as the more favorable body for motorists.
- IAS (Independent Appeals Service): The IAS considers appeals against operators who are members of the International Parking Committee (IPC). The appeals process here is often considered less transparent by motoring groups.
Warning on Reduced Rate: Note that appealing at this independent stage (POPLA or IAS) typically results in the parking operator withdrawing the ability to pay the parking charge at the reduced 14-day rate. If you lose the independent appeal, you will be liable for the full, higher amount.
Step 5: Seeking Further Advice and Legal Action
If your formal appeal is rejected by the independent body, or if the parking company is not a member of an accredited trade association, your options narrow, but you still have recourse:
- Contact Legal Services: Motoring organizations like the RAC offer legal advice to its members. The Citizen’s Advice Bureau is also an invaluable free resource for initial legal guidance.
- Pay Under Protest: If you wish to avoid the risk of court action, you should pay the fine, but formally state that you are ‘paying under protest’. This preserves your right to try and reclaim the money later via a small claims court action (though this path is often not cost-effective).
- Court Action Risk: You can choose not to pay, and the parking company will then decide if it is worth the time and cost of taking you to the small claims court. If the parking company takes you to court and wins, you will have to pay the fine plus their court costs.
- Report to Trading Standards: If you believe the ticket was issued unfairly, or the company’s practices are misleading, you can contact the Citizens Advice to report the parking company to Trading Standards.
Understanding the difference between a Parking Charge Notice and a Penalty Charge Notice is the first step in defending your rights as a motorist on private land.
Want to protect yourself against any losses after an accident? Get legal expenses insurance from just £15 a year with RAC Legal Care Plus.
Get complete peace of mind at the roadside and at home with RAC breakdown cover today.